Law Articles And Legal Issues

Supervisors from Mars...Employer Defense Attorney, Clifton Smith, Comments on the California Supreme Court's Expansion of Managerial Immunity

Oceanside, CA (PRWEB) June 18, 2008 -- For employees who believe that their supervisors are alien life forms, there is now judicial confirmation that supervisors are not considered "persons" against whom liability may be imposed for acts of retaliation under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (Government Code § 12940(h)). So says a majority of the California Supreme Court. As employees attempt to identify their supervisors' planet of origin, the Court continues to find a way to expand the scope of managerial immunity for personnel decisions under California law.

In the case of Jones v. The Lodge at Torrey Pines Partnership 42 Cal. 4th 1158 (2008), a sharply divided California Supreme Court ruled 4-3 that employers, not individual supervisors, may be held liable for acts of retaliation under California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (the FEHA), California Government Code §§ 12940, et.seq. This ruling expanded existing protections announced a decade earlier in Reno v. Baird, 18 Cal. 4th 640 (1998), in which the California Supreme Court held that employers, not supervisors, may be held liable for acts of discrimination.

As reported in the Court's written decision, Plaintiff, Scott Jones sued the Lodge and two supervisors for various causes of action, including constructive discharge, harassment, discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation and retaliation. Jones, a manager with a history of promotions, was responsible for the restaurant, bar, catering and banquet events at the Lodge. Jones complained of harassment from the food and beverage director, Weiss, who was also his immediate supervisor, and the kitchen manager, Steen. Only two causes of action went to jury trial: A claim for sexual orientation discrimination against the Lodge only, and a claim for retaliation against both the Lodge and Weiss. At trial, Jones reportedly testified that Weiss and Steen engaged in gay-bashing jokes, and made offensive, sexual remarks about female employees and Jones's sexual orientation. Jones also claimed that he was subjected to disciplinary action in retaliation for reporting his claims of harassment. Jones asserted that these retaliatory acts ultimately led to his constructive discharge (forced resignation). The jury found for the Plaintiff, Jones, on both causes of action, awarding compensatory damages of $1,395,000.00 against the Lodge and $155,000.00 against Weiss. On appeal, the California Supreme Court reversed the judgment against Weiss only.

The judicial dividing line in this case was the Court's interpretation of the meaning of the term, "person". Despite the FEHA's use of the term, "person", in its identification of those subject to liability for acts of retaliation (Government Code § 12940(h)), the Court's majority still decided that the Legislature did not intend to impose personal liability against supervisors for decisions characterized as retaliatory acts, a decision sharply criticized by Justice Moreno in his dissenting opinion. In his dissent, Justice Moreno accused the majority of ignoring the plain meaning of the statutory language. Justice Moreno encouraged the Legislature to act to clarify the meaning of the statute.

In a clearly, pro-business stance, the majority reasoned that a supervisor should not be subject to the ever present threat of litigation every time that he/she makes a personnel decision, which is an unavoidable and essential function of supervision. Shielding a supervisor from liability for acts of discrimination or retaliation encourages a supervisor to act to protect an employer's interest, without threat of financial ruin. Otherwise, the Court reasoned, imposing individual liability would have a chilling effect on the exercise of managerial discretion.

Employers should take little solace in this ruling since they remain vicariously liable for the acts of their managing agents, as evidenced by the judgment in excess of one million dollars against the Lodge in this case. Supervisor training to prevent sexual harassment in employment (California Government Code § 12950.1), which is actually mandated for employers with 50 or more employees, offers a cost-effective alternative to reduce the risk of financial loss resulting from violations of California's Fair Employment and Housing Act.

CE Smith Law Firm is the small employer's resource in California, supporting a union-free environment, educating and empowering it clients to effectively manage their employees, insuring that its clients remain labor law compliant and serving as its client's advocate, to advance and protect their interests.

###

Other Article Sites

findabook.com  moneycd.info  a-mortgage.info   about-lemon-laws.info  aboutstudentloans.info
all-about-publishing.info  auctions-articles.info  bestcollege-university.com  bestispconnection.com
biblefolder.com  blogger-website.com  books-used.info  brokers-guide.info  buywindows.info  cable-dsl.info
career-miner.com  carpel-tunnel.info  cashinaflash.info  cashloanreviews.info  casinobell.com  chat-house.info
clearmycredit.info  collegeloantips.info  crones.info  depression-articles.info   dirnic.net  dishguides.info
divers-below.com  expodog.info   financewizz.com  fire-insurance.info  getgood.info  handleit.net   it-idea.info
health-supplies.info  hosting-right.com  insidealert.com  insurance-facts.info  jobs-employment.info
justgood.info  lookgold.net   lowcost-travel.info  money-source.info  myhostzone.info  numisblog.com
peoplesearchfinder.info  pr-articles.info  realeas.com   refinancing-guides.info  spyware-remove.info
telelot.info  the-law.info   toppaid.info  travel-deals.info  travelcorrect.com  wedding-guide-site.com
your-blog.info  your-credit.info

Other Law Sites
Search The Internet For Other Law Sites

Law Books
Search For Law Books At FindaBook.com

New York City Construction Accident Lawyers Lobby for Safer New York State Labor Laws
Recent construction accident news supports David Perecman and Doug Fanning's stance that New York State labor laws need to be updated and strengthened to protect worker's rights.

Tax Attorney Roni Deutch Analyzes Proposed Tax Laws in New Featured Blog
After nearly seven months of blogging, tax attorney Roni Deutch has posted a new featured blog analyzing the causes and possible outcomes of a new proposal that is being backed by the Internal Revenue Service. The proposal is part of President Bush's 2008 budget, and attempts to lower the gap in what taxpayers pay and what they should pay in taxes, by requiring many Internet companies to collect personal data from their users.

Los Angeles Divorce Attorneys, The Family Law Company, Opens a New Office in Beverly Hills
Los Angeles family law attorney and founder of The Family Law Company Pamela Wright opens a new office in Beverly Hills. The Family Law Company offers high-quality legal services at affordable rates for divorce, paternity, child custody and child support actions because justice doesn't have to cost a fortune.

Lemon Law Attorney, Dana Lynn Tarquini, Featured at Lemon Law Administrators Conference
Ms. Tarquini, one of the country's most prominent lemon law attorneys, participated in panel discussion at the 10th anniversary lemon law administrators conference in Atlantic City.

Tax Attorney Web Site Warns of Upcoming Tax Laws in 2008
TaxAttorneyHelp.com, an online network of tax attorneys, is preparing to assist taxpayers with new laws in the coming year.

Kirsten Branigan Joins McDonald Law Group, LLC Adding Depth in Employment Law
Kirsten Branigan and Nancy McDonald join forces with a shared passion--advocating for advancement of women in the practice of law.

Understanding The Law...Criminal Law
The following Q&A's have been provided to help you better understand Criminal Law.

Legal Resource Local-Attorneys Expands to Include Divorce Law
Local legal resource website Local-Attorneys has announced that it is expanding to cater to divorce law specialists and visitors in need of advice. Web users will be able to browse local law firms who specialize in every sort of legal vertical. Find the best advice and attorneys in the industry.

Fresno Family Law Attorney Says Collaborative Law Can Provide Smoother and More Affordable Divorce
Fresno family law attorney Erin Rhames-Childs says collaborative law can help people can reduce the conflict and cost of divorce litigation.

Houston Bankruptcy and Family Law Practice Announces Affiliation with Houston Civil Litigation, Business Law and Immigration Law Firm
Houston bankruptcy attorney Michael Busby of Busby & Associates joins forces with Carlos Peniche & Michael Rojas of Peniche and Rojas to offer Texans comprehensive legal services - from divorce, personal injury and civil litigation to contract disputes, employment law and immigration services.

Elizabeth A. Kreitzer, Certified Family Law Specialist, Joins Klinedinst Family Law Group
The California-based law firm of Klinedinst PC has added Elizabeth A. Kreitzer, Certified Family Law Specialist, to its expanding Family Law practice group. Ms. Kreitzer's addition, combined with the strength of the firm's existing litigation teams, will help ensure that every client receives sophisticated, professional and compassionate representation, Ms. Kreitzer is the recipient of the Michael C. Shea Chair in 2005, and adds a wealth of family law knowledge to the department. She is experienced in working with sophisticated clients handle complex family law issues, including divorce, paternity and custody disputes, prenuptial agreements, adoption proceedings, and other family law matters.

Divorce Lawyer Says Families Do Not Belong In The Court Of Law
Fresno divorce attorney Erin Rhames-Childs says that the court of law is no place to divorce. The courts are overworked and understaffed - leading to poor legal decisions that are not in the best interests of those involved. Collaborative divorce is a way for couples to divorce while maintaining their dignity, making decisions that truly are in the best interests of their children and preserving their finances. Collaborative divorce is quicker, cheaper, and better for maintaining functional relationships for after the divorce is over.

Copyright Infringement Cases Can Teach Us To Obey Copyright Laws
Copyright infringement cases can be both costly and time consuming. Considering copyright infringement is something that isn?t as easily defined as theft or speeding, there are numerous copyright infringement cases changing the way copyright law is viewed in the U.S. By reviewing a few of these copyright infringement cases, you can get a better idea of what is, and what is not, acceptable use of copyrighted works.

Tax Attorney Site Answering More Questions on New Tax Laws
TaxAttornyHelp.com, an online tax law attorney service provider, has answers to questions on new tax laws that affect filers in 2008.