Law Articles And Legal Issues

Lemon Law - Mechanics Flat Rate Pay System

There is a relationship between the auto repair technician Flat Rate pay system and the incidence of unrepaired Lemon Vehicles. It is more direct than one might think.

What is Flat Rate Pay System?

It's old-fashioned piecework plain and simple. Imagine picking peaches. Instead of an hourly wage, you get paid a penny a peach.

The auto manufacturer establishes fixed times for every conceivable repair. This includes everything from a bulb replacement to installing a new engine. Most dealerships charge between $60 and $70 dollars an hour for warranty repairs. It's in the dealership's contract with the manufacturer that they may only charge for the repair hours provided by the manufacturer.

Here are some of the links in this chain of cause and effect:

- The modern automobile is computer controlled and complex.

- Vehicle computers fail and these software/computer hardware failures appear to be other non-computer components in the vehicle.

- Modern diagnostic tools don't isolate faults; they suggest possibilities, areas of vehicle systems that might be at fault.

- The technician is rewarded for how fast he or she works, not how well.

- The dealership makes good money for warranty and non-warranty repairs.

- Quality and customer satisfaction are advertising slogans, not a way of life in the work place.

- Quite often poorly trained mechanics cause more trouble than existed in the vehicle before attempted repairs.

- The slow technician, whether excellent or not, will barely make a living and certainly receive hard talk from his supervisors.

Are all vehicles declared lemons at buyback unrepairable? Probably not.

Given these conditions, the chances a faulty vehicle will meet lemon vehicle legal definitions, i.e., four repair attempts during the warranty period, are significantly increased.

The Dealership Situation

Here's an example of what dealerships consider a bad, bad thing.

1. A car that is still under warranty has a defective transmission. The manufacturer assigns transmission replacement a time to repair of 4.5 hours. At $65/hour for warranty repairs, the dealership gets paid $292.50 by the manufacturer for this warranty repair. (Remember, the manufacturer pays for warranty repairs.)

2. If it takes the dealership's technician 6.75 hours to complete the repair. The dealership must eat 2.25 hours of technician repair time.

3. If the technician takes 3.9 hours to make the repair, the dealer will still charge the manufacturer 4.5 hours, and even though the technician only spent 3.9 actual hours on the job, he will be paid for 4.5 hours.

4. In the first case the service manager at the dealership complains to the technician, "sorry, Joe, the manufacturer reduced repair times again. You know those %^$%^$# aren't part of the real world, they don't know how long it takes to make orange juice!" He's also going to strongly "encourage" the technician to make the repair in less time than that assigned by the manufacturer.

It is an unjust system with no redeeming value for the honest technician or the dealership. Who's the big loser? You guessed it, the customer.

All the players in this game have very different viewpoints. Let's review them.

Manufacturer

The manufacturer screams about being ripped off by the dealership for inflating warranty repair hours, and that the dealership is doing unnecessary warranty repairs. Both accusations are probably correct, but not necessarily for the reasons suggested by the manufacturer.

Dealership

The dealership moans and groans about how unfairly the manufacturer establishes and even reduces the hours allowed for each warranty repair. They also claim they have no say in how the hours were established in the first place. Both of these accusations are entirely correct. Manufacturers also have a policy of not paying for repeated warranty repairs to fix the same malfunction. How does the dealership respond to this? It's not good. If the dealership sees a repeat problem, they must somehow make it appear to be different that the original malfunction. Charitably, this can lead to untruthfully describing a problem on the repair order. Remember, four repair attempts for the same problem is one of the criteria that defines what is and is not a lemon. Where's the incentive to do honest, quality work?

Mechanic

The immediate effect of manufacturers cutting the flat rate (piece work) times is a reduction in the mechanics paycheck. In order to maintain the same pay rate the mechanic must work that much faster. Faster is not consistent with quality repairs, quite the contrary. At the same time the manufacturer is demanding higher quality repairs. It's a Catch 22 wherein everyone loses. Add to this inadequate training at best and one has a recipe for the Lemon connection.

Consumer

The consumer has no idea about the complex business relationships that exist between manufacturers and dealers, nor do they have any interest. Why should they? The consumer's needs are quite simple. Sell me a car for a decent price that does what the advertisements say it will. If it needs a repair, have someone competent and well trained do the work and for Pete's sake get it right the first time.

Final Thoughts

There's something seriously wrong with the system. It's a system that rewards all the wrong things. Like many such systems in other parts of American business, this system rewards quantity, not quality.

There seems to be an inherent inability among business managers to draw a connection between quality and business success. The manufacturer sets up quality rewards systems, such as Ford's Blue Oval, then turn around and cut the work/task hours arbitrarily, probably to allow a senior executive to look good by improving the bottom line of a quarterly report. The result is an immediate drop in quality work at the dealership. There are so many contentious viewpoints, and so little willingness among the players to correct the situation.

I wish I could offer some hope to consumers that efforts are being made to resolve this situation, but I haven't seen any such evidence. Perhaps this essay will at least bring some sense to a nonsensical mess.

Donald Ladew, Staff Writer for Norman Taylor & Associates, is a professional writer and author of numerous articles on quality,customer service issues and many other subjects. This article approved by Norman F. Taylor Esq. For more information about this most important subject, please read Lemon Law - The Standard Reference Guide, Norman F. Taylor Esq. ISBN 0-9760058-0-8 http://www.lemonattorneys.com or http://www.normantaylor.com For further inquiries, Mr. Ladew may be reached at: donald@normantaylor.com Phone: 818-244-3905.

Other Article Sites

findabook.com  moneycd.info  a-mortgage.info   about-lemon-laws.info  aboutstudentloans.info
all-about-publishing.info  auctions-articles.info  bestcollege-university.com  bestispconnection.com
biblefolder.com  blogger-website.com  books-used.info  brokers-guide.info  buywindows.info  cable-dsl.info
career-miner.com  carpel-tunnel.info  cashinaflash.info  cashloanreviews.info  casinobell.com  chat-house.info
clearmycredit.info  collegeloantips.info  crones.info  depression-articles.info   dirnic.net  dishguides.info
divers-below.com  expodog.info   financewizz.com  fire-insurance.info  getgood.info  handleit.net   it-idea.info
health-supplies.info  hosting-right.com  insidealert.com  insurance-facts.info  jobs-employment.info
justgood.info  lookgold.net   lowcost-travel.info  money-source.info  myhostzone.info  numisblog.com
peoplesearchfinder.info  pr-articles.info  realeas.com   refinancing-guides.info  spyware-remove.info
telelot.info  the-law.info   toppaid.info  travel-deals.info  travelcorrect.com  wedding-guide-site.com
your-blog.info  your-credit.info

Other Law Sites
Search The Internet For Other Law Sites

Law Books
Search For Law Books At FindaBook.com

Credit Repair: Exercise Your Legal Rights!
Take Control Don?t imagine that other people always play fair

Chapter 11 Bankruptcy Law Information
Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code governs the process of reorganization under the bankruptcy laws of the United States.When a troubled business decides that it is unable to service its debt or pay its creditors, it can file (or be forced by its creditors to file) with a federal bankruptcy court for bankruptcy protection under either Chapter 7 (liquidation) or Chapter 11.

Do You Know Which Ivory Is Legal?
Mammoth ivory is an exquisitely beautiful material medium reaching far back into our artistically creative humanistic past, and still touches us today due to the well preserved mammoths being excavated throughout Alaska and Siberia, and the traditional ivory carving artists For the larger ivory findings, those pieces will be individually sold just as all the other variations of tusks

TALX Selected by United States Postal Service to Provide The Work Number® and Unemployment Tax Services
Contract with nation’s second largest employer provides catalyst for added growth at TALX Corporation.

Haynes and Boone Selected as a Law Firm of the Year by Private Equity Real Estate Magazine
Haynes and Boone, LLP was selected as the North American Law Firm of the Year for 2007 in the Transactions category of the Private Equity Real Estate (PERE) Annual Awards.

Personal Injury Attorney Jeff S. Korek Advises Visitors to New York City How to Protect Their Legal Rights When Injured
A specialist in construction accidents and medical malpractice and partner in the firm Gersowitz, Libo & Korek, Jeff S. Korek discusses three things tourists to New York City must know if they become injured. New York City has a dense population, is fast paced and plays host to more than 40 million annual visitors; numerous personal injuries occur. The city has complex laws governing many different injuries, with varied stipulations and time limits. Therefore, it's vital that as soon after the accident as possible, visitors seek the counsel of an experienced personal injury attorney familiar with all the laws.

Your Internet Business and the Law
With the number of internet businesses being established on the internet setting new records seemingly every business day, it is no surprise that a growing number of these end with serious business and legal difficulties. A common excuse appears to be a claim of ?ignorance to the law? or the fact that many are simply unaware of the existing regulations and laws. Sadly, as you might expect, ignorance is not a recognized defense for the legal requirements.

Property Tax Fear and Loathing
If you have read my other articles here, you might have noted the psychological approach towards subject matter. Therefore, as you have probably guessed from the title, this article on property tax is not going to be any different. After all, the years spent earning degrees in neurobehavioral psychology should not be wasted.

Last Chance For Up To $2000 Solar Income Tax Credit According to Green Energy Solar Inc
Green Energy Solar Inc has great news for Arizona income tax payers. There is still time to claim one of the remaining tax credits of up to $2000 for upgrading your home to solar hot water. "What began quietly in January of 2006 has quickly become a boon to Arizona homeowners looking to save significantly on their utilities, reduce foreign energy dependence and even improve home value. But if Arizona homeowners wait much longer they will miss out completely because the federal solar tax credit expires permanently December 31st 2008," says Kelly Dancer, CEO of Green Energy Solar Inc (Arizona's leading solar company).

Leopard Solutions Announces New Website Updates And Legal Recruiter Interviews
Leopard Solutions announces updates to the Leopard List, Leopard Reporting and two exclusive legal recruiter interviews.

Equipment Manufacturers | Distributors Boost 2008 Sales by Touting Section 179 Tax Deduction
Informational website www.Section179.Org reminds equipment manufacturers, distributors, and resellers that by helping their customers understand the Section 179 Tax Deduction, they can help boost their own sales.

Typhoon Touch Technologies Enters into Licensing Agreement with Electrovaya Inc., Settling Litigation : Acknowledgement of Validity and Infringement
Typhoon Touch Technologies, Inc. (OTCBB: TYPT) (www.typhoontouchtech.com), owner of foundational intellectual property in the area of portable touch-screen computers, announced today that defendant Electrovaya Inc. (TSX: EFL) has settled the patent infringement lawsuit brought against Electrovaya and other defendants by Typhoon and Nova Mobility Systems, Inc. for an undisclosed sum representing a royalty payment of at least 20% on past and future sales of its Scribbler Tablet PCs in the United States. Additionally, Electrovaya formally recognized the validity of Typhoon?s patents at issue in the litigation and acknowledged infringement of one or...

Immigration Law ? Classes Of Parent Visa And Application Process Fact Sheet
Classes of Parent Visas

Florida Lawyer Don Conwell receives the highest certification from The Florida Bar as a specialist in Civil Trial Law
G. Donovan Conwell, Jr. has been certified by The Florida Bar as a specialist in Civil Trial Law. Certification is the highest level of recognition given by The Florida Bar for competency and experience within an area of law.